Sugar-free confectionery is not a sweetness problem. Sugar provides bulk, glass structure, crystallisation control and mouthfeel, and a high-intensity sweetener replaces none of them. The polyol carries those jobs. This note compares the main polyols by the properties that decide a confectionery batch: crystallisation, cooling, hygroscopicity and texture.
Why the polyol is the recipe
In a hard candy, the sugar and glucose syrup form a glass. Replace them with a high-intensity sweetener and there is no glass, no mass and no shine. A polyol or a fibre has to fill that role. Isomalt is chosen for hard candy because it forms a clear, low-hygroscopic glass; maltitol is used in chocolate because its sweetness and mouthfeel are close to sucrose.
The polyol also changes the process. Isomalt cooks and moulds differently from sucrose; maltitol can brown; erythritol crystallises at a different rate. The recipe that works with one polyol does not transfer unchanged to another.
Cooling and mouthfeel
Erythritol and xylitol dissolve endothermically, which produces a cooling effect. In chewing gum and mint, that is a benefit; in chocolate, it can read as a strange cool note. Maltitol and isomalt are less cooling, which is why they are used where a sucrose-like mouthfeel matters.
The cooling effect also depends on particle size and on the rate of dissolution. A fine powder dissolves quickly and cools quickly; a granule releases more slowly. The same polyol at two particle sizes can produce two different sensory results.
Humidity and shelf life
Sorbitol and xylitol are hygroscopic; erythritol and isomalt are much less so. In a humid climate or a pack that is not a high barrier, a hygroscopic polyol can pick up water, become sticky and lose the crisp texture. A low-hygroscopic polyol is easier to protect, but it may not deliver the same mouthfeel.
The pack is part of the formulation. A foil wrapper, a metallised film and a paper twist have different moisture-barrier properties. A candy that passes at 50% relative humidity can fail at 70% in the same pack. Test the finished product in the pack, not only the polyol in a jar.
Texture, moisture and the pack
The polyol is only half of the texture story. The pack, the storage humidity and the crystal form decide whether the candy stays crisp or turns sticky. Test the finished item in the real pack at the target humidity, and record the polyol, the particle size and the moisture together.
The polyol also has to be named in the specification. A product sweetened with maltitol is not the same as one sweetened with erythritol, and the texture and the moisture behaviour differ. The specification and the recipe should be designed together.
A confectionery selection guide
The selection is not a ranking. The right polyol is the one that delivers the texture, the process and the shelf life for that product. Taste the finished item, not the powder, and test it after storage in the real pack.
- Hard candy: isomalt for a clear, low-hygroscopic glass; maltitol for a different sweetness.
- Chocolate: maltitol for body and sweetness; erythritol for a cooler, lower-sweetness profile.
- Chewing gum: xylitol for cooling and sweetness; sorbitol for cost and humectancy.
- Chews: sorbitol and maltitol for softness; erythritol for a cleaner, cooler finish.
- Tabletop: erythritol and xylitol for flow and cooling; a high-intensity sweetener for the top note.
What to take away
- A polyol replaces bulk and texture, not only sweetness.
- Cooling and hygroscopicity decide mouthfeel and shelf life.
- Particle size changes dissolution and the sensory result.
- Cooling, hygroscopicity and the pack are part of the recipe.
Go deeper
Polyols range
The six published polyol specifications, with assay, moisture and particle size.
Read the referenceCite this note
Rainwood Sweeteners. “Polyols in sugar-free confectionery: bulk, cooling and humidity.” Published 20 November 2026. https://sweeteners.rainwoodbio.com/blog/polyols-sugar-free-confectionery/